Underinsured motorist coverage is often misunderstood, even by drivers who carry it on their auto insurance policies. These misunderstandings can lead to unrealistic expectations after an accident or incorrect assumptions about how and when coverage applies. Understanding common misconceptions about underinsured motorist coverage helps policyholders make informed decisions and avoid surprises during the claims process.
Clarifying these misunderstandings is essential for evaluating whether coverage limits are adequate and how this protection fits into an overall insurance strategy.
Misunderstanding That Underinsured Coverage Applies Automatically
One common misconception is that underinsured motorist coverage applies automatically after any accident involving another insured driver. In reality, coverage is triggered only when the at-fault driver’s liability limits are exhausted and damages exceed those limits.
If the at-fault driver’s insurance fully covers the losses, underinsured motorist coverage does not apply, even if the injured party believes compensation is insufficient.
Belief That Any Low Liability Policy Triggers Coverage
Many drivers assume that underinsured motorist coverage applies whenever the at-fault driver carries low liability limits. Coverage is not based solely on the other driver’s limits, but on whether total damages exceed those limits.
If damages fall within the at-fault driver’s liability coverage, underinsured motorist benefits are not available, regardless of how low those limits may seem.
Assumption That Coverage Pays Immediately
Another misunderstanding is that underinsured motorist coverage pays medical bills and other expenses immediately after an accident. This coverage typically applies later in the claims process, after liability coverage is resolved.
Policyholders often rely on health insurance, medical payments coverage, or other resources while the underinsured motorist claim is pending.
Confusion Between Uninsured and Underinsured Coverage
Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage are frequently confused due to their similar names. Uninsured motorist coverage applies when the at-fault driver has no insurance at all, while underinsured motorist coverage applies when the driver has insurance but not enough.
Using the wrong coverage type can delay claims and create confusion about available benefits.
Misunderstanding About Coverage Limits
Some drivers believe underinsured motorist coverage pays on top of the at-fault driver’s liability limits in all cases. In many policies, payments are reduced by the amount already received from the at-fault driver’s insurer.
The actual benefit available depends on policy structure, state law, and how limits are applied.
Belief That Higher Limits Always Mean Full Coverage
Carrying higher underinsured motorist limits does not guarantee full compensation for all losses. Coverage remains subject to policy limits, exclusions, and legal rules.
Severe injuries can still result in uncovered expenses if damages exceed even high coverage limits.
Assumption That Property Damage Is Always Covered
Many drivers assume underinsured motorist coverage includes property damage. In many states, underinsured motorist coverage applies only to bodily injury.
Vehicle repairs may require collision coverage or separate property damage protection, depending on the policy.
Misunderstanding Consent-to-Settle Requirements
Policyholders may not realize they need their insurer’s consent before settling with the at-fault driver’s insurer. Failing to obtain consent can jeopardize underinsured motorist benefits.
This requirement is often overlooked but plays a critical role in protecting the insurer’s subrogation rights.
Belief That Coverage Applies Regardless of Fault
Underinsured motorist coverage does not apply if the insured is fully or primarily at fault for the accident. Comparative negligence rules may reduce or eliminate benefits based on fault allocation.
Understanding fault requirements helps manage expectations after shared-fault accidents.
Assumption That Coverage Is the Same in Every State
Underinsured motorist coverage rules vary significantly by state. Requirements, definitions, and payment methods differ based on local laws.
Drivers moving between states or purchasing coverage in different jurisdictions should not assume uniform coverage.
Why Clearing Up Misunderstandings Is Important
Misunderstandings about underinsured motorist coverage can lead to financial surprises and frustration after an accident. Knowing how the coverage actually works helps policyholders choose appropriate limits and follow required procedures.
Clear understanding supports better decision-making and reduces the risk of uncovered losses caused by underinsured drivers.
Related Guides