Collision coverage is one of the most widely carried auto insurance coverages, yet it is also one of the most misunderstood. Many drivers assume collision coverage provides broader protection than it actually does or misunderstand how it works alongside other coverages. Clarifying common misunderstandings helps prevent claim surprises and improves coverage decisions.
Collision coverage is effective when used correctly, but only within its defined scope.
Collision Coverage Covers Any Type of Vehicle Damage
One common misunderstanding is that collision coverage pays for all types of vehicle damage. In reality, collision coverage applies only to damage caused by impact with another vehicle or object.
Damage caused by theft, weather, fire, vandalism, or animals is not covered under collision coverage. These losses fall under comprehensive coverage.
Understanding the cause of damage is essential to knowing which coverage applies.
Collision Coverage Only Applies When You Are Not at Fault
Many drivers believe collision coverage applies only when another driver causes the accident. Collision coverage actually applies regardless of fault.
Whether you caused the accident or not, collision coverage can still pay for repairs or a total loss, subject to the deductible.
Fault affects premiums and claims history, not collision coverage eligibility.
The Deductible Applies Only If You Are at Fault
Another misconception is that the collision deductible applies only in at-fault accidents. In reality, the deductible applies whenever collision coverage is used.
Even if another driver is clearly at fault, the deductible is still owed when filing a collision claim. The deductible may be reimbursed later if recovery is successful, but it applies initially.
Deductibles are part of the coverage structure, not a penalty for fault.
Collision Coverage Pays Off Your Loan Automatically
Collision coverage does not guarantee full loan payoff after a total loss. It pays only the vehicle’s actual cash value minus the deductible.
If the loan balance exceeds the vehicle’s value, a remaining balance may still be owed. Collision coverage reduces loss severity but does not eliminate loan risk.
Loan payoff concerns require separate consideration.
Older Vehicles Never Need Collision Coverage
Some drivers assume collision coverage is unnecessary for all older vehicles. While value matters, age alone does not determine coverage usefulness.
Older vehicles with high repair costs, limited replacement options, or essential daily use may still benefit from collision coverage.
Coverage decisions should consider value, repair costs, and financial impact, not age alone.
Collision Coverage Includes Rental Car Costs
Collision coverage does not automatically include rental or temporary transportation expenses. Rental reimbursement coverage is a separate optional coverage.
Without rental reimbursement, drivers may need to pay out of pocket for transportation while repairs are completed.
Understanding coverage separation prevents unexpected expenses.
Collision Coverage Always Repairs the Vehicle
Collision coverage does not guarantee repairs. If repair costs exceed the vehicle’s value threshold, the insurer may declare a total loss.
This decision is based on economic practicality, not the driver’s preference to repair.
Total loss outcomes are a normal part of collision coverage.
Using Collision Coverage Always Raises Premiums
Filing a collision claim does not automatically result in a premium increase. Premium impact depends on fault, claim history, and insurer guidelines.
Some claims may have little or no effect, especially if accident forgiveness applies.
However, repeated or severe claims increase risk classification over time.
Collision Coverage Replaces the Need for Liability Coverage
Collision coverage protects only the insured vehicle. It does not cover damage to other vehicles or injuries to others.
Liability coverage is still required to address legal responsibility. Collision coverage complements liability coverage but does not replace it.
Each coverage serves a distinct purpose.
Collision Coverage Is Required by Law
Collision coverage is not legally required by states. It is required by lenders and leasing companies, not traffic laws.
Once a vehicle is owned outright, collision coverage becomes optional from a legal perspective.
Legal requirements should not be confused with financial protection needs.
Why Clearing Up Misunderstandings Matters
Misunderstandings about collision coverage lead to poor coverage decisions and claim frustration. Knowing what collision coverage does and does not do allows drivers to use it effectively.
Clear expectations help drivers build balanced policies that provide meaningful protection without unnecessary cost.
Related Guides